GroceryPeanut Butter/Jelly/SpreadsPeanut Butter/Jelly/SpreadsSort By:RelevanceAlphabeticalRelevancePrice High To LowPrice Low To HighNo elements found. Consider changing the search query.List is empty.$4.9916oz($4.99/lb)Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut ButterAdd To Cart$6.5928oz($3.77/lb)Jif Peanut Butter CreamyAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - Wild FruitAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - Apricot PreservesAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - RaspberryAdd To Cart$5.2928oz($3.02/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - CreamyAdd To Cart$3.9920oz($3.19/lb)Welch's Concord Grape JamAdd To Cart$4.7912oz($6.39/lb)Smucker's Strawberry JellyAdd To Cart$7.4916oz($7.49/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - Organic CreamyAdd To Cart$8.997.6oz($18.93/lb)Nutella & Go! - Hazelnut Spread & Pretzel Sticks, 4 PackAdd To Cart$6.9910oz($11.18/lb)St. Dalfour Fruit Spread - ApricotAdd To Cart$9.9928oz($5.71/lb)Justin's Peanut Butter ClassicAdd To CartSave $2.00$11.99$9.9916oz($9.99/lb)Once Again Almond Butter - Creamy, Unsweetened & RoastedAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Cherry PreservesAdd To Cart$3.9932oz($2.00/lb)Smucker's Concord Grape JellyAdd To Cart$5.6918oz($5.06/lb)Smucker's Preserves Red Raspberry With SeedsAdd To Cart$3.9915.5oz($4.12/lb)Smucker's Low Fat Grape ConcordAdd To Cart$5.9916oz($5.99/lb)Smart Balance Omega Natural Creamy Peanut ButterAdd To Cart$3.7916oz($3.79/lb)Jif Peanut Butter - Extra CrunchyAdd To Cart$3.2915oz($3.51/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Natural Super ChunkAdd To CartSave $0.50$7.99$7.4936oz($3.33/lb)Teddie Super Chunky Peanut ButterAdd To Cart$4.9918oz($4.44/lb)Smucker's Strawberry Jam - SeedlessAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Blueberry PreservesAdd To Cart$4.7912oz($6.39/lb)Smucker's Orange MarmaladeAdd To Cart$3.9916oz($3.99/lb)Marshmallow FluffAdd To Cart$6.9926oz($4.30/lb)Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter - Smooth UnsaltedAdd To Cart$3.7916oz($3.79/lb)Jif Peanut Butter - Natural Creamy, Low SodiumAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Seedless Blackberry JamAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Damson PlumAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Red Currant Jelly.Add To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Seedless Red Raspberry PreservesAdd To Cart$4.7912oz($6.39/lb)Smucker's Preserves ApricotAdd To CartSave $0.70$4.69$3.9916oz($3.99/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - SmoothAdd To Cart$5.6918oz($5.06/lb)Smucker's Preserves StrawberryAdd To CartNew Low Price$3.59$3.2918oz($2.92/lb)Food Club Strawberry Preserves 18 ozAdd To CartSave $0.70$4.69$3.9916oz($3.99/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - Smooth With FlaxseedAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - PeachAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - BlueberryAdd To Cart$2.991.9oz($25.18/lb)Nutella & Go! - Hazelnut Spread & Pretzel SticksAdd To Cart$7.4940oz($3.00/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter, CreamyAdd To Cart$5.2926.5oz($3.19/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Natural CreamyAdd To Cart$2.991.8oz($26.58/lb)Nutella & Go!Add To Cart$3.9920oz($3.19/lb)Welch's Concord Grape JellyAdd To Cart$7.2910oz($11.66/lb)Felix Wild Natural LingonberriesAdd To Cart$4.9912oz($6.65/lb)Smucker's Red RaspberryAdd To Cart$5.6918oz($5.06/lb)Smucker's Preserves ApricotAdd To Cart$3.9918oz($3.55/lb)Welch's Simply Natural Concord Grape Spread - Squeeze BottleAdd To CartSave $0.50$4.49$3.9910oz($6.38/lb)Polaner All Fruit Spreadable Fruit - StrawberryAdd To CartSave $0.50$4.49$3.9910oz($6.38/lb)Polaner All Fruit Spreadable Fruit - Seedless RaspberryAdd To CartSave $0.50$4.49$3.9910oz($6.38/lb)Polaner - Real Mint JellyAdd To Cart$3.9910.5oz($6.08/lb)Reese Jellied Mint SauceAdd To CartSave $1.80$7.29$5.4916.5oz($5.32/lb)Crofter's Organic Premium Fruit Spread - StrawberryAdd To CartSave $0.50$7.99$7.4936oz($3.33/lb)Teddie All Natural Smooth Peanut ButterAdd To Cart$7.298.8oz($13.25/lb)Bonne Maman Hazelnut Chocolate SpreadAdd To Cart$3.2916oz($3.29/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Creamy, No Sugar AddedAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Red Raspberry JamAdd To Cart$6.9914oz($7.99/lb)Lotus Biscoff Spread - CreamyAdd To Cart$10.9926.5oz($6.64/lb)Nutella Hazelnut Chocolate SpreadAdd To Cart$3.2916.3oz($3.23/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Creamy Reduced FatAdd To Cart$3.2916.3oz($3.23/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Creamy Roasted Honey NutAdd To Cart$6.9926oz($4.30/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - SmoothAdd To Cart$6.4912oz($8.65/lb)Chivers Olde English MarmaladeAdd To Cart$4.7930oz($2.55/lb)Welch's Concord Grape JellyAdd To Cart$3.2916.3oz($3.23/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Super ChunkAdd To Cart$2.9912oz($3.99/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter CreamyAdd To Cart$5.2928oz($3.02/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - Super ChunkAdd To Cart$10.991ea($10.99/ea)Stonewall Kitchen Red Pepper Jelly Tree Ramekin Gift SetAdd To Cart$4.7912oz($6.39/lb)Smucker's Seedless Strawberry JamAdd To Cart$5.6918oz($5.06/lb)Smucker's Orange MarmaladeAdd To Cart$3.4912oz($4.65/lb)Smucker's Concord Grape JellyAdd To Cart$5.6912.75oz($7.14/lb)Smucker's Preserves Sugar Free Red Raspberry With SplendaAdd To Cart$4.9912.75oz($6.26/lb)Smucker's Sugar Free With Splenda Orange MarmaladeAdd To Cart$5.9912oz($7.99/lb)Trappist Preserves Strawberry PreservesAdd To Cart$3.7916oz($3.79/lb)Jif Peanut Butter - Creamy, Reduced FatAdd To CartSave $0.50$9.99$9.4911.75oz($12.92/lb)Stonewall Kitchen Maple Bacon Onion JamAdd To Cart$4.9915.5oz($5.15/lb)Full Circle Organic Strawberry Fruit SpreadAdd To Cart$4.9917oz($4.70/lb)Full Organic Circle Grape JellyAdd To Cart$10.9910oz($17.58/lb)Barney Butter Almond Butter SmoothAdd To Cart$6.9926oz($4.30/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - Super ChunkyAdd To Cart$8.997.3oz($19.70/lb)Nutella & Go 4 PackAdd To CartSave $0.50$8.99$8.498.5oz($15.98/lb)Stonewall Kitchen Organic Classic Fig JamAdd To Cart$6.2916oz($6.29/lb)Justin's All Natural Peanut Butter - ClassicAdd To CartSave $0.50$9.99$9.4912.5oz($12.15/lb)Stonewall Kitchen Wild Maine Blueberry JamAdd To Cart$7.9917oz($7.52/lb)Stonewall Kitchen Spicy Corn RelishAdd To Cart$8.9916oz($8.99/lb)Sunbutter Original SpreadAdd To CartNew Low Price$4.99$4.4932oz($2.25/lb)Food Club Strawberry Preserves 32 ozAdd To Cart$3.2916.3oz($3.23/lb)Skippy Peanut Butter - CreamyAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - StrawberryAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - BlackberryAdd To CartSave $0.50$4.49$3.9910oz($6.38/lb)Polaner All Fruit Spreadable Fruit - ApricotAdd To Cart$4.9915.5oz($5.15/lb)Full Circle Organic Raspberry Fruit SpreadAdd To CartSave $0.50$9.99$9.4912.5oz($12.15/lb)Stonewall Kitchen Raspberry Peach Champagne JamAdd To CartSave $0.70$4.69$3.9916oz($3.99/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - Super Chunky UnsaltedAdd To Cart$5.6918oz($5.06/lb)Smucker's Red Raspberry Seedless JamAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - Orange MarmaladeAdd To Cart$7.4913oz($9.22/lb)Bonne Maman Preserves - FigAdd To Cart$14.9916oz($14.99/lb)Full Circle Organic Creamy Almond ButterAdd To Cart$4.7917oz($4.51/lb)Musselman's Apple ButterAdd To CartSave $0.70$4.69$3.9916oz($3.99/lb)Teddie Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter - Super ChunkyAdd To Cart$11.9916oz($11.99/lb)Sunbutter Organic SpreadAdd To Cart